Verlenging naturalisatietermijnen

Reactie

Vraag1

The current 5-year rule strikes a fair balance between integration and the rights of long-term residents. Increasing the requirement to 10 years would have several negative effects for both residents and the Netherlands as a whole:
1. Disadvantage for the Netherlands’ Economy and Workforce Needs
The Netherlands faces a shortage of skilled workers in various sectors, including technology, healthcare, and engineering. Many migrants filling these gaps are highly skilled professionals who want to commit long-term. Citizenship gives them stability, a stronger sense of belonging, and motivation to build their careers in the Netherlands rather than seeking opportunities elsewhere.
By doubling the waiting time, the Netherlands risks losing valuable talent to other European countries with more favorable naturalization policies. This would weaken the competitiveness of the Dutch economy at a time when attracting and retaining skilled workers is crucial.
2. Unnecessary Delay in Integration
Citizenship is one of the strongest incentives for newcomers to integrate fully into Dutch society, including learning the Dutch language, participating in the labor market, and contributing socially. Extending the period to 10 years will discourage integration rather than promote it.
3. Disadvantage for Families and Children
Families who have settled in the Netherlands, pay taxes, and contribute positively will face greater uncertainty. Children born or raised here will be disadvantaged if their parents have to wait double the time before becoming Dutch citizens.
4. Economic and Social Contribution Already Proven by 5 Years
After 5 years of continuous legal residence, people have already demonstrated their commitment and contribution. Many work, study, and support the economy. Adding another 5 years does not add value but only creates barriers.
5. Risk of Inequality
Extending the period could create a class of “semi-permanent residents” who are integrated in practice but denied equal rights for too long. This risks social inequality and reduces trust in institutions.

Conclusion
For these reasons, I strongly urge the government to maintain the current 5-year requirement for naturalization. This policy supports integration, family stability, and fairness, while also serving the Netherlands’ own long-term interests in building a strong, skilled, and loyal workforce.